Dear Readers, I am against a Hard Fork that would steal, destroy or freeze someone's money.steemCreated with Sketch.

in #steem6 years ago

Hello all,

I'm sure you have seen this proposed hard fork code:
https://github.com/steemdev/steem/pull/1/commits/807d5e0e0aef8c6f940bd003fd8e7404d738138a

Basically what it does is freezes or disables the Stake owned by Steem Inc.

It's bad enough this is even proposed as a thing, but it is no mere intellectual exercise. It may shock you to know that this fork is actually being discussed as a real possibility of something that could be done, or should be done!

I am against any such fork

I want to state clearly that I am against any such fork. It is thievery, plain and simple (or vandalism). It is communism that destroys property, the integrity of money. It goes against the ideas the principles that were introduced by Satoshi and Bitcoin. This fork will tear Steem apart and destroy it, much worse than anything Ned would do.

If someone wants to clone Steem into another chain, something akin to Whaleshares, Weku or the like, that's fine, but don't do harm to an existing, functional chain.

If we can freeze Ned's stake, then we can freeze anyone's. Perhaps later, people will decide that I am an evil bank and hardfork to take my money away.

Eth and DAO

I know someone might bring this up. In case of Eth and DAO, I wasn't a fan of that either, but at least in that case, the DAO was hacked, so you could at least make a weak argument that you were fixing a hack by hardforking the money back.

The fork above isn't fixing any sort of hack, but instead destroying the property of Steem Inc. Even if you hate Ned and feel Steem Inc is incompetent (and I'm certainly no fan of either one), you can't fix this problem with a far bigger evil.

Sort:  

@neoxian,
No doubt this fork should not be happened! I think witnesses might not be that fool to implement it! If they do, that mean we leave STEEM to a better chain!

Cheers~

I'd like to know who are the people who would be for that kind of fork, I just don't understand the logic behind that. It would undermine everything Steem stands for. I'm glad top witnesses made these kind of statements like you today, should of been few days earlier imo.

And what could be the logic behind that? It is sabbotage!

I hate this shit because I don’t know enough. @neoxian, I appreciate the info

Posted using Partiko iOS

Here here @neoxian and Thank You for Your Support as Always of the BEST Community on Steemit (In My Opinion) @ssg-community

Damn.... This is scary 😧

I fully agree.

Scary crap.

What started out as a wonderful experiment in democratic blogging has turned into a real piece of shit!

Oh my.
I am against controlling others funds without understanding any of this.
It makes common sense that if it is your funds, you control them.