The Three-Ring Circus at Year's Turn: Oil Drowns, Crypto Staggers, Stocks Levitate

Thursday, January 1, 2026

Markets took a collective breath today—literally, since American exchanges are closed for the holiday. But the silence is deafening. With the S&P 500 still perched at 6,856 points and looking almost offensively cheerful after a 16.6% gain in 2025, I'm left staring at three entirely different financial universes colliding in real time, and none of them are talking to each other.

Let me paint you the disconnect.

Oil is having what we'd politely call a reckoning.

WTI crude is down roughly 18% for the year, hitting lows not seen since 2021. At the start of 2026, WTI is trading around $57.42 per barrel—and here's the thing that should terrify anyone who remembers 2014: this is structural, not cyclical. OPEC+ isn't defending prices anymore. They've switched tactics entirely. After initially supporting prices through production curbs, the group accelerated the return of supply during 2025, gradually shifting focus from defending prices to protecting market share.

Translation: they gave up. The cartel is dead. Long live the surplus.

The International Energy Agency is projecting a market oversupply of 3.8 million barrels per day next year. JP Morgan is setting targets in the $50s. Goldman is flirting with $40-50. The EIA forecasts Brent crude will average $55 per barrel in Q1 2026 and remain near that price for the rest of the year. Oil on water has ballooned to over a billion barrels worth—that's crude just floating around waiting to come ashore, because the economics are so grim nobody's in a rush.

The question that haunts every energy sector investor: how low does it have to go before someone stops pumping? Answer: apparently lower than $57. Because prices below the $60 per barrel mark are expected to put the brakes on America's shale growth, but we're already below $60, and the pumps are still running. This suggests we're headed for true supply destruction—the only kind that actually sticks. By which I mean: more wells abandoned, more capital budgets slashed, more Texas families moving to whatever-the-tech-hub-is-now.

Bitcoin is limping along like it's forgotten how to party.

The crypto that was supposed to be the trade of 2026 started the year at $87,600. Down 5% year-to-date. Worse: December would mark a rare instance of Bitcoin closing lower for three consecutive months, an event that has occurred just 15 times in history. Think about that. Fifteen times in a decade and a half of continuous trading, Bitcoin had three consecutive down months. We just did it. We're living in the 15 times.

The optimists will tell you the setup looks clean. Institutional Bitcoin ETFs have sucked in billions. The market cap has crossed $3 trillion. Bitcoin's total crypto market dominance sits at 57.37%—meaning the king still owns the kingdom, even if the kingdom is smaller. Analysts are openly floating $100K-$150K targets by end of year.

But here's what they're not saying out loud: the bounce in January is not guaranteed. Bitcoin is likely to stabilize between $90,000 and $100,000 as markets digest gains, and most of that's just hopium dressed as technical analysis. What's actually happening is a market that ran 130% in one year and then got smacked. The retail capitulation is real. The institutional "opportunity" narrative is compelling. But crypto has a way of reminding you that every $10K move feels different when you're holding it.

And then there are stocks, living in their own dimension.

Wall Street ended 2025 like nothing happened. The S&P 500 ended 2025 at 6,845.5 points, with analysts expecting it to reach anywhere from 7,100 to 8,000 by year-end 2026. Deutsche Bank thinks we're getting 16.87% more upside this year. Morgan Stanley says 7,800. HSBC says 7,500. Even the cautious voices sound bullish. Inflation is benign, interest rates are trending lower and earnings are trending higher, and that's goldilocks for stocks, one strategist crowed.

Except... the Fed just signaled it's not cutting rates. About 80% of bets for January's Fed meeting are on the Fed holding steady at current levels. And interest rates aren't actually "trending lower"—they're stuck. The Fed's December minutes showed major internal friction. Several officials felt it could be "some time" before another cut. Meaning: the goldilocks scenario depends on narrative control and earnings magic, not fundamentals.

What's holding stocks up is the same thing that's always held them up in years like this: the belief that someone will take action if things get too weird. The "Trump put" is real. The rebalancing flows at the start of the year will be substantial. And earnings season hasn't started yet, so nobody has to actually defend valuations in blood.

So here's where my head is:

Oil is headed lower because supply is infinite and OPEC lost control. That's straightforward.

Crypto is consolidating below psychological levels and needs either a catalyst (regulatory clarity, an ETF approval, rate cuts that actually happen) or retail FOMO to make a run. Right now it's a coin flip.

Stocks are expensive, momentum-driven, and levitating on the belief that the Fed will rescue everything. Until the Fed acts—or until earnings disappoint—that's probably enough to keep the party going.

But they're not the same party anymore. That's the real shift. The old correlations are dead. Oil crashed while stocks soared. Crypto is trying to stay relevant while stocks don't even notice. The Fed is being pulled in three directions at once: inflation hawks saying hold the line, growth worriers saying cut already, and financial conditions hawks watching leverage explode.

Markets are supposed to reflect reality. Right now they're reflecting wishes. And wishes, eventually, get tested.

Come Friday, when the machines turn back on, we'll start finding out which wishes turn into orders, and which ones turn into noise.

I'll be watching the tape.

---

Markets reopen Friday. The real year starts then.