RE: Is Patriotism Biblical?
Hi @garthfreeman,
I'm going to try to respond to your entire post.
Let's see.
It seems to me that you are confusing patriotism for righteousness. Standing up for what is right isn't synonymous with patriotism, in fact the actions of nation states is often quite opposed to righteousness.
No, I'm not confusing it with righteousness. The bible speaks about what a "righteous nations," is.
Proverbs 14:34 Righteousness exalteth a nation: but sin is a reproach to any people.
A nation is either righteous or it's not. That doesn't mean that every single person walks in the righteousness of Christ, they never did in Israel, but it does mean that those who are in Christ do! And it reflects within the nation itself.
In fact, there are entire chapters within the scriptures dedicated to the subject of nations either walking in righteousness or not, Israel itself went into captivity more than once for complete unrighteousness. In Sodom and Gomorrah, Abraham asked God if He would spare the nation if 100, 50, 10, and all the way down to a very few amount of people walking in righteousness. The response was that if 100 and even less were righteous, Sodom and Gomorrah would be spared. (Genesis 18:16-33.)
Leviticus 26 goes into great depth about the nation walking in God's righteousness, or not, and what the effects are for either case.
So does the book of Deuteronomy, as well as many other instances within the Holy Writ.
In the US, we have a federal government that engages in all kinds of immoral activity. It steals, it has unjust money, it fails to provide an adequate justice system, it fails to take care of the poor... Have you ever read the Old Testament? How many times is Israel chastised for failing to take care of the poor and not enforcing justice?
That's interesting that you ask if I've ever read it. Yes, I have. I've studied it, and guess what? There has never been a completely righteous nation! Not even Israel. Every nation's leaders partake in the things that you listed. Israel had what the Bible calls, "righteous leaders," and its share of very UNRIGHTEOUS leaders. Ever read about Ahab and Jezebel?
Isreal came into very distressful times whenever the nation walked contrary to God's instruction. It wasn't just about a government who doesn't take care of its poor...Which btw, America has one of the greatest welfare systems in the entire world.
In comparisons with nations that actually have welfare systems.
If you'd like to really break that down, Jesus encouraged individuals to give to the poor. He didn't state that any government should steal from those who have to give to the poor. Righteousness is a voluntary giving, led by God.
Also complicating the issue is the fact that there are many different ideas about what is right, wrong, and American. What if you were stoked about the way things were going under Democrat rule, but hate the way things are going now? Are you supposed to cheer lead policies you oppose?
IF you actually read the article, I covered that in it...please read it before asking questions that have already been addressed.
This idea that the US is somehow a special Christian nation is laughable. Sure, some of the founding fathers were Christian, but most weren't, and they intentionally built a secular government. It was a wise thing to do. But to say the nation has always acted Christian is to completely gloss over the brutal violence that has been a hallmark of establishing and maintaining this country. Every problem the US has is solved with violence, or threat of violence.
This isn't some made up idea. Without even considering the earliest Americans, but Americans today, 70.6% identify with being CHRISTIAN. Making this a Christian Nation! There are small percentages of Christians in Muslims nations, (for example) but those nations are majority Muslim and are called MUSLIM nations...
This idea that the US is somehow a special Christian nation is laughable. Sure, some of the founding fathers were Christian, but most weren't, and they intentionally built a secular government. It was a wise thing to do. But to say the nation has always acted Christian is to completely gloss over the brutal violence that has been a hallmark of establishing and maintaining this country. Every problem the US has is solved with violence, or threat of violence.
It's not some abstract idea that America has been blessed, take a look around you. This nation has been one of the most prosperous, and powerful nations in HISTORY. Unless you are not a Christian and have no idea what the bible says, this point is a mute argument.
How could a Jesus follower get behind an organization like that? If you want to be patriotic, then you can patriotically support your true country, The Kingdom of God.
I am convinced that you didn't even read the article....
I never stated that we must support ungodly things. I even addressed the situation with Daniel...
By the way, your quotation from Psalms isn't a blanket statement saying that any nation who is mostly Christian will be blessed. The passage is specifically referring to the ancient Israelites. The LORD chose Israel as his heritage, and the "nations" are the people God did not choose. See Deut 32:8-9.
You think that posting one verse or claiming it says what you want it say, makes your point. Well, I love posting verses...and actually reading them.
So here goes. Each and every one of these verses speak about nations, and rather than reply to me without having even read the article or without looking at the whole matter, I'd like to request that you step down from your high-horse, and listen to what God's word says. And then try to respond using wisdom rather than complete rudeness.
Acts 17:26 And hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth, and hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds of their habitation;
Isaiah 14:26 This is the purpose that is purposed upon the whole earth: and this is the hand that is stretched out upon all the nations.
Isaiah 2:4 And he shall judge among the nations, and shall rebuke many people: and they shall beat their swords into plowshares, and their spears into pruninghooks: nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more.
Psalms 33:12 Blessed is the nation whose God is the LORD; and the people whom he hath chosen for his own inheritance.
We can also get into how God appoints leaders to nations! That's an awesome study, and since you want to attack the nation itself, based on your political views, it's a very good subject to study.
There are hundreds of biblical mentions of NATIONS, in the scriptures that I haven't even touched upon in this response.
If you respond, please read the post and the entire response first.
Also please try to be civil.
Try to remove your political issues and consider what the bible actually says.
If you think that American Christians today have no say, and their prayers for the nation don't matter, and if you think the American Christians today should sit back and allow things like satanic prayers in their cities, then I suggest you really read what the bible says about the power of prayer, and abiding in Christ, and taking a stand for what's right according to GOD'S word.

About confusing patriotism for righteousness, you missed my point entirely. Patriotism, as in the love for one's country, is not the same as a nation being generally righteous. Your article is about how Christians should be patriotic, not about whether the nation is righteous.
Further, you seem to be missing the fundamental point I'm making entirely. The point is that there is no connection to nations states and the Kingdom of God. There is no sense in which love for a nation is needed, or a benefit to a walk with Jesus.
What do you think Jesus would think about a drone strike on a Pakistani wedding party because there might be a suspected terrorist at the wedding?
I did read your article, but I don't think you are understanding my point at all. Take this quote, you say
This shows you are missing my point entirely because to support a state government that acts ungodly is to support ungodly things. I am trying to tell you that the state is ungodly!
I can tell this is a thought you don't like by the "high horse" comment and your assumption that I'm politically driven, but you're incorrect. Really, I'm talking about what the bible actually says. I'm not going to carpet bomb verses for you, but the "Nations" is a whole theme running through the Old Testament. God was working His plan of salvation out through Israel because of the promises to Abraham. Jesus fulfilled those promises, so now God doesn't deal with people as nations anymore. We are either "in Christ" of we aren't.
This isn't some pie in the sky idea. We are the people of God. We are the new Kingdom of Priests. That means our political allegiences are to our King.
I certainly do NOT think that American Christians are wasting their time praying. I totally believe in the power of prayer. You have again gotten angry because you misunderstood me. Again, it is Patriotism, which is a love of and support for one's country, that I am saying are not compatible with Christianity. No state could ever be good if run by men, unless the man is Jesus.
Fortunately for us, He Lives!
Garthfreeman, you didn't even read the article, and I didn't miss your point at all. I responded to each point individually. Next time read the actual post before responding. If you have a view you want to share, write your own article, don't hijack someone else's.
You've been answered point by point. So kindly, drop it.
I actually love discussing actual points, especially when the points are based on the actual subject of the article and scriptures are discussed. I'm not interested in opinions.
Well, you are still not getting my point. I did read the article and I explained how you have misinterpreted what I said.
If you don't want comments on your posts then what is the point? Are you just wanting a slap on the back? What good is that. You posted an article trying to encourage Christians to be patriotic. I think that is leading them into danger, and love of the state is love that should be diverted to Jesus. I'm sorry, but if you post in a public forum I don't see what the problem is. If you were standing on the street corner preaching about Allah I would confront you then as well.
You never addressed my point, the main one, which is that the state is evil and supporting an evil state is counter to the Kingdom of God.
Did you know that nobody likes to be told to drop it?
I don't think you like discussing points at all. In fact, I'm picking up a bit of hostility from you. Nevertheless, I did make points. My question about you reading the Old Testament was rhetorical: I gave you the benefit of the doubt without splashing a bunch of verses in your face.
You know, most of what we know or think we know is really just opinions.
Take care!
.
?