You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Collective vs. Private Ownership (Part 2 of a Series)

in #economics8 years ago

"Communism is what you do when you are a decent human being that values life higher than material goods."

Ah yes. Welcome to that mythical land where the tools of survival are too mundane to worry about and scarce resources don't exist unless it's to argue about "saving the planet". Then resources are so scarce we could run out tomorrow.

"'Collective ownership' is a catch phrase that is used to obscure what is really being discussed, much like 'lying hitlery' or 'trumped up trickle down'.
It is simply a term that has caught some fish for the oligarchs."

Gee, whatever happened to the proletariat owning all of the means of production like it mentions in the communist manifesto? Is that not collective ownership?

"The flaw in Larken's argument is that he attempts to paint communism as a rule by force nightmare while he advocates rule by force for the oligarchs that will be at the top of his crapitalust pyramid.
Unless you eliminate wages, banks, and money you will always serve those that have more than you, this is what an-crap is all about, keeping the sleeple on the farm and growing wool."

By all means, let's do away with money and go back to being hunters and gatherers with a life expectancy of 30 years. Because if you want to have a modern industrial civilisation, minerals have to be extracted and processed, trees have to be planted, grown, harvested and turned into lumber. Cereals, fruits and vegetables have to be grown, harvested and brought to market. Cattle have to be raised and slaughtered. Since one man can't possibly produce all those things, people have to trade for what they need and we found out long ago that bartering can't cut it, so you need some kind of medium of exchange.

This caring about other things than material stuff is all very nice, but if you want to propose a model for society, you have to get off the clouds and start dealing with reality.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.18
TRX 0.15
JST 0.028
BTC 62984.76
ETH 2472.53
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.55