I am so proud: The Dutch are changing their law to "Everybody is organ donor, unless..."

in #health7 years ago

Great news from my home country. The Dutch finally got their new organ donation law through parliament. They are changing the law to "Everybody is an organ donor, unless you actively decline."

I know this sounds very harsh on a lot of people. I know a lot of people will find it irresponsible and morally wrong. Not me, and I will explain you why. Remember this is just MY opinion, so dont feel offended and feel free to debate on this.

As many of you know or not know, I work in surgery. I see a lot of shit. I see a lot of people dying. I helped remove a lot of organs from brain dead patients helping other people in the past. This feels good, it feels like somebody can still do something for another human being after their passing.

Before this law the original Dutch law was: 'When you turn 18 years old, you will receive a letter from the government with the question if you want to be an organ donor. You had options. Yes/ No / yes, but not this and this organ. You had to send the form back with your choice and your signature. People are lazy, people dont want to think about these kinds of things (because dying is scary), and people dont feel like walking to their mailbox to post something. A lot of potential donors were missed in this way. In the end family members always had the last saying on if organs in the end would be donated or not. And this is a good thing!!! But what is not a good thing, is that a lot of times disaster strikes when you least expect it. Something happens and all of a sudden you are brain dead. And you did not discuss this with your loved ones on what you thoughts are of organ donation. Are you cool with it/ do you find it your moral obligation/ or are you super anti? Hell, a lot of people dont even know from their loved ones if they want to be buried or cremated. So often when disaster strikes: families are in shock and mourning. And they choose not to donate their loved ones organs, because they dont know how their loved ones opinion about this was, because maybe that person was too lazy, or didnt want to talk about it. You just dont know.

That law changed this week!!

So the Dutch law got through parliament that everybody is a potential donor now, unless they fill in that they dont want to be a organ donor. Apart from the fact that this is a fantastic way to open peoples eyes again to debate about the topic, this is also a way to potentially receive more donors. As you all know on yearly basis still a tremendous amount of people die while waiting for organs on the transplant list. Often they would have a match, but that match never signed up for the program. This law is a good reason to wake people up and speak up when they dont want to donate their organs. And this is also okay!!! Lazyness now will automaticly mean you sign up to donate your organs.

Does the family have anything to say in this ?

Yes of course, the family has again any right say up and reject the donation of organs. Same as it was, family has the last saying. And yes, this also means that families still might have that terrible debate when all of a sudden something happens to their loved ones.

So, why is this a good thing then?

To me, and again this is just my opinion, it is good because I find that donating your organs should be a normal thing when you die. Just like you give away your furniture when you dont like the style anymore. You dont just throw them away, you reuse them. I know this sounds very plastic, but maybe that is what working in surgery does with you. You see people more as persons with broken body parts. And those parts are fixable and replaceable.

I dont believe in an afterlife, so I believe organs go to waste when they are not used after passing. I believe the body is an empty shell used by the mind. When the mind is gone, they empty shell is useless. Let me get personal for a second: I lost one of my best friends years ago in an accident, and the idea that he helped 5 young people getting their lives back to me is something so generous. And because he had his donation papers with him when this accident happened, we all knew this was what he wanted. No questions asked, this was a natural thing to do. 5 people got extra time with their families, because my friend was clear on his choice. Isnt this something everybody should consider doing?

Or let me get even more touchier. Is it even fair to receive an organ when you are terminally ill, but not being willing to donate one? Let this sink in for a second, and decide for yourself. Im not judging, Im just asking you to think.

Well the Dutch prove again to be controversial but also revolutionary. I like this new law. Im proud of it. I dont mean to offend anyone with this article.

Image: Pixabay

Sort:  

To be honest i kind of like this idea. Many people die because they do not get the life saving organs they need, while the organs that could be used to save these people are wasted.

If you have the opportunity to opt-out? I guess I persoanally dont see any issue. When you are dead you cannot use your organs anyway :)
Might as well give someone a fighting chance..

I’m an voluntary organ donor, so i suppose you could say my opinion is somewhat biased!

The opt-out option is always there! You can say in advance that you do not want to be in.
And when the moment turns out to be there, your family are still the ones saying yes or no.. So plenty of options still!

And yeah, I share your opinion, cant no anything with your organs while being dead, so might as well give em to somebody ill!
My opinion is same way biased, Im voluntarily and I also find it annoying that everybody wants organs but nobody is willing to donate them

oh, and for the last question, my initial reaction is unfair. But then again, it may depend on a case-to-case basis. There might be some major underlying reason why the person wouldn't want to donate any organs :)

Well, thats a totally different thing. I find everybody can have their reasons for refusing to donate..thats all cool.

But lazyness! Thats is not a good reason for not donating. I remember when we all got the letter turning 18 in school and almost everybody would say 'ow uhh yeah..I still have to fill it in...' and months later is was still the same..

My opinion just is that its a the organs are so useful after dying, its a pity to leave them in empty soulless shell.

And yeah..if your death is good for anything, it will at least me something good to other people. God will appreciate that as well ;)

Here in Puerto Rico when you go to the doctor they ask if you want to be an organ donor, then enter the answer in the medical info software. All our medical info is saved on pc, that way doctors just have to make a few clicks to know our health issues and if we want to donate organs.

Yeah like in a central database. Its perfect! But here (or Holland let me rephrase) so often the info on IF people want to be a donor get lost in limbo because nobody wants to talk about it of course. Now you really have to express your opinion about NOT being a donor.

Where I live now, its not an option unfortunately. Its too far away time wise from everything else, and most people find it disgusting based on their religious ideas. I find it a bummer, but its a cultural thing. But so many people with diabetes and they are all on the transplantlist...but religiously they find that okay.

Hypocrisy ..pfff

True! People still have to learn so much about the importance of donating organs. So many people have been saved because of that. Ignorance is a bad disease!

Thats actually really good. Better than just throwing them away. Congrats Dutch Gov.

I think so too, the are really trying to chance it in a progressive way. And you still have the option to say no. But then you have to get off your lazy ass and actively say no. I like that. Encourage people

@karinxxl gelieve voor je engeltalige blogs de tag #alldutchenglish te gebruiken en enkel voor Nederlandstalige posts de tag #alldutch te gebruiken.

Ik ga er met je nog effe over discussieren op discord... eigenlijk lijkt het me helemaal niet handig om twee verschillende tags hiervoor te gebruiken. Als jij als gebruiker zoekt op leuke dingen om te lezen over Nederland (niet als curator maar als gewone steemian), dan gebruik je toch eerder de tag #nl of #alldutch. #alldutchenglish is echt een beetje te ver gezocht wat mij betreft. Deze tag gaat over Nederland en dan zal ik eerder nl gebruiken als alldutchenglish.

Maar wat ik zeg: we hebben het er nog wel effe over!

I believe there's an afterlife; but that doesn't mean we'll need our organs for it.
I heard of a scheme in the US, members receive organs from members.
The only way to become a member is to agree to donate your organs to other members.
Opting into or out of organ donation entirely, as both donor and recipient simultaneously.
As a fan of the free market, I'd like to see people able to sell their organs, with proceeds going to their estates, but that's not likely any time soon.

I wouldnt like the free market on this, because people will go into desparate measures for some cash. And frankly, if enough people would voluntarily be donor...it woulnt be necessary!

Maybe the scheme isnt such a bad thing??

If I am dead "for sure"... like "really for sure"... then yes, you can have my organs.

However, if I wake up (after being dead) and you are in the middle of taking my organs, I want them put back in...

But seriously... yes... I agree with the law... just because someone hasn't taken the time to donate their organs while they are alive, doesn't mean after they are dead that they shouldn't be put to better use.

Nice alert on this... I think all countries could follow this example.

Hehehee yeah...being really dead is a decent demand for all of this!

Exactly thats the point. You can still easily say you dont want to donate, but hopefully now peoples lazyness wont effect others on the waiting list anymore.

It would be fantastic is other countries would even consider doing this.

Amazing news, so proud of the Netherlands!

As we should be! I find it revolutionary and very future thinking and really am proud from a distance!!

This would never be optional here in Sint Martin, even though it is actually a part of Holland

It's a shame right, so many people could benefit from it and I also believe it's a way to give a chance to part of that someone who passed away to still be alive.

Totally agree. What I noticed on my friends passing back then, it gave a piece of pride and relief that is wasnt all for nothing that he died!

Your post was selected to be included in my "Diamond in the Rough" series. It's goal is to promote high-quality posts made by new steemians (red fish and minnow) thereby helping them get the exposure they need to grow and thrive within the Steemitverse. You may check the related post Diamonds in the Rough @sandalphon.

Yeah cool thx!!! Let me check out what you guys are doing there!

If you put it that way, I agree 100% :)
I mean, it's for a good cause. The dead won't have any use for those organs anyway.
Besides, isn't it a good feeling that before you move on to the great beyond, you know that you did something good. Who knows, that organ may even save a life :)