You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: SC-S29|Geo-Quest Mystery – Week 1: The Origin Point

in Traveling Steem • 7 days ago (edited)

Thank you for your participation in Geo-Quest Mystery – Week 1: The Origin Point. Here is a re-evaluated and fair evaluation of the post by @bossj23, taking into account the user’s comment/objection and the clarifications provided.

Evaluation Summary (Re-Review)

CriteriaScoreComments
1. SteemAtlas Pin & Description1.25 / 1.5The pin and coordinates are present, and the location is identified (“Marina Service Road” near Ibom Icon Hotel & Resort). For full clarity, the pin/post should still include a clean visitor-friendly line with city + country and one clear landmark reference.
2. Creativity of Mission & Hidden Clue1.85 / 2.0Re-checking with the author’s explanation: the hidden clue is indeed done through an emoji-code where the emojis’ meanings form a word. The concept “quest point → origin point → paradise” is also creative and fits the mystery theme well. Minor deduction only because the code is not instantly readable without the explanation (but it remains fair and not too obvious, as requested).
3. Speem.watch Proof Video1.9 / 2.0Based on the participant’s confirmation, the required spoken “starting point” message is present in the video, and the video is valid proof. Slight deduction only if recognizable markers are not consistently clear throughout the clip.
4. Storytelling Quality1.7 / 2.0Strong sense of exploration, curiosity, and reflection. The journey feels immersive and personal. A slightly tighter focus (less repetition in some sections) would make the narrative even stronger.
5. Photos Quality & Authenticity1.5 / 1.5Photos appear personal, consistent with the story, and support authenticity and atmosphere very well.
6. Engagement (Comments / Clue Guessing)1.0 / 1.0Updated based on the author’s objection: the participant confirms they commented on two posts and guessed hidden clues. This meets the requirement for full engagement points.

Final Score: 9.2 / 10

Remarks:
This re-review confirms that @bossj23 followed the rules more closely than the first evaluation suggested especially regarding engagement, the spoken line in the video, and the emoji-code hidden clue. The entry stands out for its “mystery quest” structure and strong nature-focused exploration. The main improvement to reach an even higher score would be to make the SteemAtlas location description more precise (city/country/landmark in a single clear line) and slightly tighten the storytelling flow.

Hidden clue confirmed: PATIENT

— Geo-Quest Mystery Jury

7 days ago in Traveling Steem by
$0.00
    Reply 3
    Sort:  
  • Trending
    • [-]
     7 days ago (edited)
    • Thanks for the invite review, but I did comment on 2 people's posts and even found it their hidden codes. Check it Sir.

    😣....Painful
    🥾....Adenture
    🤔.....Thought
    🐝.....Insect
    🫩....Exhuasted
    ......Notably
    🙏🏽.....Thanks

    • If you check the video well, you'll see hear that I said the spoken line you wanted to hear....I followed the rules squarely . I'm PATIENT
    • You stated that we can use it emojis for hidden cues and I used emojis squarely. You also stated that it shouldn't be too obvious. I didn't make it obvious. If you're bringing all the emojis together, you'll see that I created a word with the initials of these emojis..... Let's see...

    I Know that you're the jury, but also check out these objections

    $0.00
      Reply
      [-]
       7 days ago 

      No problem i will review your post.

      $0.00
        Reply
        [-]
         6 days ago 

        Thanks for the review. I'll do better next week . Noted all the corrections and will apply them in my next post.

        $0.00
          Reply