Television Review: Lost (Season 6, 2010)
When Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse committed to concluding their labyrinthine television phenomenon in 2010, they embarked upon what was arguably television's most daunting narrative challenge. After six years of accumulated mysteries, temporal paradoxes, and an ever-expanding ensemble cast, Lost arrived at its final season burdened by expectations that no conclusion could reasonably satisfy. The resulting seventeen episodes represent a fascinating, flawed, and frequently frustrating endeavour—one that alternates between moments of genuine emotional transcendence and mechanical plot contrivance, between bold mythological ambition and the disappointing realisation that many questions would remain forever unanswered.
The season's most immediately controversial decision was the introduction of the "flash-sideways" narrative device—an alternate timeline in which Oceanic Flight 815 never crashed. This structural innovation, debuting in the bifurcated premiere LA X, was initially intriguing. The cold open depicting a successfully landed flight, with Jack Shephard enjoying his complimentary beverage whilst Locke engages in casual conversation with Boone, offered a tantalising glimpse of roads not taken. Yet as the season progressed, this alternate reality increasingly revealed itself as the show's Achilles heel.
The fundamental problem with the flash-sideways was one of dramatic stakes. Unlike the flashbacks of the first three seasons, which provided essential character exposition and psychological depth, or the flash-forwards of Season Four, which generated genuine narrative tension, the sideways timeline existed in a peculiar limbo. As in What Kate Does, these segments often played like benign, slightly twee fan fiction, wherein darker characters were conveniently redeemed through banal domesticity rather than earned transformation. The contrivance of having every significant character—from major survivors to peripheral Others like Ethan and Mikhail—inexplicably cross paths in metropolitan Los Angeles transformed a sprawling mythology into something resembling a provincial village.
Episodes such as The Package and Lighthouse exemplified this weakness. Jin and Sun's sideways storyline devolved into melodramatic soap opera, complete with a shooting and pregnancy reveal that felt engineered for shock value rather than character insight. Jack's introduction of a previously unmentioned teenage son, David, in Lighthouse smacked of desperate late-game retconning. The cameo appearances by deceased characters—Keamy, Mikhail, Dr. Arzt—whilst initially diverting, soon became emblematic of a narrative running on nostalgic fumes.
The eventual revelation in The End that this entire timeline constituted a collective afterlife—a metaphysical waiting room where the characters gathered to "move on" together—proved divisive. For some viewers, it provided a graceful, spiritual conclusion that prioritised emotional connection over cold plot resolution. For others, it retroactively rendered an entire season's worth of sideways storytelling dramatically inert. This revelation transformed the sixth season's intriguing mystery into a sentimental cop-out, a means to deliver a 'happy ending unearned by the narrative's often brutal events."
Season Six's central narrative thrust concerned the conflict between Jacob and the Man in Black—entities introduced in the closing moments of Season Five. This ancient struggle, the philosophical bedrock upon which the entire series supposedly rested, was explored with varying degrees of success. Ab Aeterno, the Richard Alpert origin story, stands as the season's unambiguous triumph. By transporting viewers to 1867 Tenerife and the wreck of the Black Rock, the episode provided genuinely satisfying answers regarding Richard's immortality, the shattered statue of Taweret, and the Smoke Monster's origins—all whilst delivering a profoundly human tragedy of love and loss. Nestor Carbonell's performance, traversing from desperate husband to broken slave to ageless advisor, demonstrated Lost at its character-driven best.
Conversely, Across the Sea—the episode devoted to Jacob and the Man in Black's primordial origins—arrived too late and explained too little. By this penultimate stage, introducing fresh enigmas (the nature of "Mother," the precise mechanics of the Island's energy) whilst pointedly refusing to address them felt like narrative malpractice. The episode's meta-textual defence—"Every question I answer will simply lead to another question"—served simultaneously as philosophical justification and tacit admission of creative exhaustion. Had audiences understood these mythic stakes earlier, the final season's thematic weight might have been immeasurably greater.
The season's handling of the Smoke Monster exemplified this tension between revelation and obfuscation. Terry O'Quinn's dual performance as the deceased John Locke and the malevolent entity wearing his form provided consistent dramatic pleasure. His portrayal in The Substitute—devilishly evil and sinister—elevated material that might otherwise have collapsed under its own mythology. Yet the rules governing this entity remained frustratingly nebulous. Why could he not enter the Temple? What precisely constituted the "infection" that corrupted Sayid and Claire? The season offered gestures toward answers—Dogen's water rituals, the mysterious "sickness"—but never the clarity that the narrative seemed to promise.
Where Season Six succeeded most consistently was in its treatment of individual character journeys, even as the machinery of plot occasionally ground against them. Dr. Linus stands as perhaps the season's finest instalment, demonstrating how the flash-sideways format could function as genuine character exploration rather than mere narrative padding. Michael Emerson's dual portrayal of Benjamin Linus—European history teacher in one timeline, desperate penitent in the other—offered a nuanced meditation on nature versus nurture. The scene wherein Island Ben breaks down, confessing his murder of Locke and his desperate need for Jacob's approval, whilst sideways Ben sacrifices his ambition for Alex's future, constituted the season's most emotionally resonant thematic statement.
Similarly, Everybody Loves Hugo provided cathartic closure for the series' most beloved character. The sideways reunion between Hurley and Libby—whose romance was brutally truncated by her murder in Season Two—was executed with genuine tenderness. The culminating kiss that triggered Hurley's flood of Island memories served as fan service elevated by Henry Ian Cusick's sensitive performance and the episode's unabashed emotional sincerity. The passing of leadership from Jack to Hurley, cemented by Hurley's destruction of the Black Rock and his subsequent decision to parley with the Man in Black, represented a meaningful transition from the man of science to the man of heart.
Less successful were the season's handling of certain character exits. Ilana's death in Everybody Loves Hugo—blown apart by mishandled dynamite—mirrored the buffoonish demise of Dr. Arzt from Season One, reducing a formidable guardian to narrative debris. The massacre at the Temple in Sundown, whilst viscerally effective, eliminated entire factions of Others with mechanical efficiency. Widmore's unceremonious execution by Ben in What They Died For—a whisper and a gunshot—felt less like tragic irony than narrative housekeeping, dispatching a major villain who had been built up across multiple seasons with startling abruptness.
The season's most devastating character moment arrived in The Candidate, with the submarine deaths of Jin, Sun, and Sayid. After three seasons of separation, the Kwons' reunion and immediate drowning constituted genuinely shocking television—"not glorious sacrifices but tragic accidents resulting from a deception that could have been prevented." Sayid's final act—rushing the bomb away from his companions—provided redemptive closure for a character who had descended into darkness. Yet even this triumph was undermined by the flash-sideways storyline's intrusion, which distracts from the high-stakes action of the main timeline just when tension should be at its peak.
The season's central antagonist, the Man in Black, embodied both its narrative strengths and philosophical limitations. His recruitment of Sawyer in The Substitute—the descent to the cliffside cave revealing the candidate numbers etched in stone—provided genuinely compelling television. The argument he presented, that the Island was not a sacred trust but a prison to be escaped, offered a seductive counter-narrative to Jacob's cryptic faith. Yet the character's ultimate reduction to a straightforward villain—irrevocably evil, capable only of shameless lie and manipulate—felt like a simplification of the moral complexity that had distinguished Lost's earlier seasons.
The season's treatment of Sayid Jarrah illustrated this moral flattening. His "infection," diagnosed by Dogen through cryptic water rituals and near-drowning, transformed one of the series' most morally nuanced characters into a blank-eyed assassin. His smile upon confronting Ben in Sundown—"pure, unadulterated malevolence"—was genuinely chilling, but it represented a reduction rather than an evolution. The sideways timeline's attempt to parallel this corruption through Sayid's violent confrontation with Keamy's loan sharks felt heavy-handed, asserting that violence was his inescapable nature across realities rather than exploring how circumstance might have offered redemption.
The End, the feature-length conclusion, embodied the season's divided legacy. On the Island, the narrative achieved functional closure: Jack accepted the protector's mantle, defeated the Man in Black through Kate's intervention, and sacrificed himself to restore the Island's golden light. Hurley's ascension to leadership, with Ben serving as his "number two," suggested a kinder, more benevolent future. The escape of Sawyer, Kate, Claire, and the others aboard Frank Lapidus's miraculously repaired Ajira jet provided cathartic release for characters who had suffered six years of captivity.
Yet the sideways revelation—the church gathering as a metaphysical waystation "outside of time"—proved the season's most divisive element. For viewers who had invested in the flash-sideways as an alternate reality with tangible stakes, its reduction to collective purgatory felt like a betrayal. The absence of significant characters—Walt, Mr. Eko, Daniel Faraday—due to casting and contractual issues further undermined the supposed completeness of this spiritual reunion. The network-imposed closing images of the Oceanic 815 wreckage, reportedly added by ABC to "soothe audiences," created a catastrophic ambiguity suggesting the entire narrative had been a death dream—a misinterpretation the writers had explicitly denied for years.
The End "succeeds as a character-driven emotional finale, providing poignant closure for the core relationships that were always the show's true engine. It fails as a mythological puzzle-box solution, leaving too many pieces on the table." The precise nature of the Island's energy, the fate of the Dharma Initiative, the mechanics of the "rules" governing Jacob and his brother—all remained frustratingly opaque.
Season Six of Lost was, ultimately, a season of necessary compromises. Constrained by seventeen episodes and six years of accumulated narrative debt, Lindelof and Cuse made choices that prioritised emotional closure over mythological completeness. The result was a season that contained moments of genuine brilliance—Ab Aeterno's tragic scope, Dr. Linus's redemptive power, The Candidate's devastating submarine sequence—alongside frustrating wheel-spinning and mechanical plot advancement.
The flash-sideways device, whilst conceptually bold, proved structurally unsound, consuming narrative real estate that might have better served the Island's remaining mysteries. The Man in Black, despite O'Quinn's formidable performance, ultimately disappointed as a villain, his philosophical complexity sacrificed for plot expediency. And the finale, for all its emotional resonance, confirmed what sceptical viewers had long suspected: that Lost was a journey where the questions would prove infinitely more compelling than the answers.
Yet even in its failures, Season Six demonstrated the ambition that had made Lost revolutionary television. It attempted to bridge science fiction and spiritual allegory, character drama and mythological epic, in ways that streaming-era television would later emulate. If the execution frequently fell short of the ambition, the ambition itself remains worthy of respect. Lost concluded not with the revelation its most puzzle-obsessed fans desired, but with the affirmation that its true subject was never the Island's secrets, but the connections forged between those who washed upon its shores. For viewers who valued character over cosmology, this was sufficient; for those who had tracked the numbers, the Dharma stations, and the temporal paradoxes with forensic dedication, it could never be enough.
In the final accounting, Season Six stands is a deeply flawed but fascinating conclusion to one of television's most influential experiments. It reminds us that even the most meticulously constructed mysteries may crumble under scrutiny, and that the only ending available is often the human one—messy, sentimental, and forever incomplete.
(NOTE: All reviews can be accesed via this link.)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo
Substack https://draxster.substack.com
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7