Between the two which is better

I am a photographer and a graphic designer. I love working on artiste from the scratch of an idea to the reality.

Recently, a promising Afro hip-hop artiste visited my studio and asked for a music art cover for his single. He made me understand that he would want the taste of the design to meet the taste of an international work. I was given 4 days to deliver.
Ordinarily, I would have used Corel draw software to design instead I chose Photoshop.

Why Photoshop? This software allows you to see the end result of your design before it is finished, if you know what I mean. Secondly, picture is easily blended when used for a graphic work. Am talking about coloration effects and manipulations.

Finally the design output gave me two different graphic works to choose from. I know steemit is place a people of high knowledge and creative authenticator can be found so I decided to bring it up for critic. Between the two which one is good enough to attract attention and stir up great expectations?

Thank you in advance as you help me to present an impeccable work of design.