You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: PSA: Do not send your Steem or SBD to Poloniex
are you sure this is poloniex related and not an issue with Steem scaling? Because I've seen people having problems with bittrex too.
are you sure this is poloniex related and not an issue with Steem scaling? Because I've seen people having problems with bittrex too.
Apart from steem scalling, poloniex disabled deposits and withdrawals of various coins before. On top of that they lock accounts, dont perform withdrawals (error status) and support doesnt answer for 6+ months. Be cautious when dealing with them.
It seems Shapeshift also has Steem as being temporarily unavailable.
If all exchanges are not trading steem but some people are able to trade and make a ton lf money. Why isn't everyone able to trade and make some money? Not cool steemit.
Not cool steemit?! Steemit has no power or direct connection to the exchange, so why would you blame them?
They could have blocked sending to the account at 2 million or 3 million. They are allowing users to get scammed by allowing transfers to go through to a place that after 4 days for many have had their funds stolen. I'm not drawing interest on my money anymore or able to trade it freely. This is theft and Steemit is facilitating the theft. Steemit should even issue a popup at this point that warns users. They have some obligation under international law to protect their users.
Some do not realize this. Think about almost every social media company you have ever done any business with or even a place where users can post content. If their is a known scam the website has an obligation to alert users of this scam. You might see notices from time to time like this:
"Please do not wire transfer money"
"Please do not give out your passwords via email."
In this case they should have a warning that says, "DO Not Send Funds To Poloniex"
Could they? I though this was a decentralized system where nobody could block other people's transactions. I think you got that wrong actually.
Steemit is just one of many interfaces to the Steem blockchain. The blockchain is immutable and censorship-proof. This is one of its selling points and I'm surprised you are not aware of this. But it also has the corolary that there is no central authority to protect you from scammers. What we can do is raise awareness and try to protect people from being scammed.
Of course, steemit it could indeed implement popups that warn you about known scammers, but I think this will go against their decentralization ideals at least to an extent.
After the huge @bellyrub scandal and scam if you try to send to that account you see this:
"Use caution sending to this account. Please double check your spelling for possible phishing."
They at least red flag the account as a possible scam. There is nothing still after MILLIONS stolen by poloniex.
So I'm wrong and you are right. They are willing to do this and it should be done for this exchange. I guess they are afraid to alienate one of the few exchanges trading steem.
They are running a social media network no matter how they classify themselves as bogusly decentralized or centralized. They could drop the social media description I guess and that could then indemnify them from having an obligation to protect their users.
Since their self-described as a social media platform they have an obligation to protect their users against known scams. How they choose to do that is up to them. Inaction is not acceptable.
What's magic about social media that it places a higher burden of user protection that another type of website.
Don't got me wrong, I absolutely view this as a huge problem, I just don't expect them to act the way you are hoping and I see that they have their reasons. I'm not even saying their reasons are valid.