You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: You do not 'have' Depression or ADHD or PTSD or [insert mental 'disorder']

in #psychology8 years ago

@invisiblegorilla You write: "I want to acknowledge that throughout this article, I’ve written words such as ‘disorder’ and ‘illness’ in quotations. This is not to minimize or negate the seriousness of sensations people who have these words applied to them, experience. However, I simply refuse to speak in the language of the pharmaceutical industry and large proportions of the psychiatric community."

You're far from alone in my experience. I personally always write "ADHD" in quote marks, for example, since I know how that particular reification was invented.

When I first heard of it some years ago, it was customary for anyone who didn't accept the American Psychiatric Association's perception of reality to be accused of being a Scientologist. I don't know if that holds true still. Perhaps things have moved on (I haven't involved myself in any discussions on this topic for a long time). My views on the subject were more likely to find me accused of having no medical or other professional training, to which my response has always been that, when people speak to me of the DSM and its stories, they are no longer in the world of medicine; we are in the world of scam artistry where I've invariably been on much more solid ground than they have.

Sort:  

Hey bobcollier, thanks for sharing. I think I recall Robert Whitaker talking about how Scientology was used to discredit the critics of psychiatry in his book, Anatomy of an Epidemic.

Yes, it did seem to be that "You must be a Scientologist" was a stock response to anybody who questioned the official line. There seems to have been a kind of war going on between the Church of Scientology and psychiatry, the American Psychiatric Association in particular, for a long time. I learn from your introductory YouTube video that you're from England. So am I, and I live in Australia now. Years ago when I was exploring what I choose to call "the psychiatric labels scam", I found that advantageous because my thinking on these things wasn't trained by the direct to consumer advertising that Americans have been and are subjected to. Speaking of which, you might be interested in the work of John Breeding, author of The Wildest Colts Make The Best Horses.

Thanks for the recommendation. Based on the Amazon description, it sounds like quite an interesting read.

He has an interesting website too at www.wildestcolts.com

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.20
TRX 0.16
JST 0.030
BTC 65776.88
ETH 2666.85
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.87