DTUBE DOES NOT WORK! REWARD POOL RAPE WARNING

in #steem7 years ago (edited)

Steem is a blockchain based on Delegated Proof of Stake. This means that those who invested more have more control over how the network is run and in principle should have greater interest in contributing to the network. This common sense principle should apply network-wide i.e. to all steem blockchain based projects but in my opinion that's not the case, Dtube being notable exception.

steem-token.png

The Steem network is based on text. This is the only thing that this network stores. This means that all projects focusing on publishing photos or movies are not well suited to Steem blockchain because neither graphic nor video files in their native formats can be stored in that particular blockchain. At least not in any viable form.

So the fact that such projects as Dtube are actively supported and promoted by those controlling significant stake in the network comes as a very unpleasant surprise. One could say that the shadier the project is then the better chances are that it would be supported ;-)

So let's have a closer look at Dtube and its "achievements" until now.

Dtube is a project aiming at creation of decentralized video platform providing an opportunity to monetize the content through an interaction with Steem blockchain. The idea is really brilliant! But implementation of this brilliant idea has just one tiny little flaw. It just doesn't work.

The whole problem is that creating a decentralized video platform is very difficult, if not impossible. It’s not that you put a movie on the Torrent network (or IPFS) and it’s already decentralized. For this you need large number of nodes that want to serve as distribution nodes for that movie. And those nodes need an incentive (ideological and/or pecuniary) to serve as such.

But Dtube model doesn't follow that type of logic and in reality is just based on Reward Pool Rape i.e. Steem blockchain inherent crime committed by Dtube operators.

Why? Because they have no interest whatsoever in maintaining movies and making them available for longer periods, because they get paid after 7 days (pocketing 15/25% of earnings). This means that hosting a movie for longer than 7 days does not make any economic sense and will result in loss of money. So what they do? It's very simple. They remove the movie file to make space for new ones which would generate fresh income and be removed after next 7 days...

How many movies survive on Dtube after 7 days money making period expires? It’s hard to say, I suspect a maximum of 1%. I made a simple bot that checks it.

Unfortunately, IPFS is a slow and problematic network, so my Bot can't operate very fast. But it has checked 10.000 movies already and found out that less than 3% still work.

From the perspective of Steem network as a whole this is just plain disaster. But it doesn't seem to prevent Dtube operators to make a living from perpetrating Reward Pool Rape.

Conclusion?

I would really like to know why this video platform is being actively supported and maintained despite the fact that it doesn't really work and its business model is founded on Reward Pool Rape? Am I missing something which would absolve Dtube for robbing Steem network?

Proofs:

Results from 2500 movies (snapshot):
https://web.archive.org/web/20180609140435/http://ressteem.tk/GaeBulg/

Results from 100 movies (in real time):
http://ressteem.tk/GaeBulg/

Source code:
https://github.com/fervi/GaeBulg

Sort:  
Loading...

One minor remark: Dtube does work. Just not for you or me 😛

Only for illuminati

Nie miałem pojęcia o tym. W takim wypadku ten serwis to jedna wielka porażka.

Zgadza się, ale dobrze płacą Dtuberom

Pytanie czy nie można jakoś wymusić na Dtube jakichś zasad? Czy są nie do ruszenia? czy tylko kasa kasa kasa? Chyba można czegoś od nich wymagać jako że działają na danym blockchainie. Wiadomo, że my nie mamy takiej siły żeby czegoś od nich chcieć ale no sam nie wiem

Dtube ma pieniądze od Steemit. Jeśli zabiorą to może zaczną coś robić. Do tego momentu nic się zrobić nie da od strony przeciętnego użytkownika platformy. W sensie można pisać o tym na Steemit, ale nie wiem czy będzie jakiekolwiek przebicie

Problemem jest właśnie tak jak wspomniałeś fakt, że Dtube nie jest zdecentralizowane chociaż miało być...
Tak samo z tym "reward pool rape". Są różne zachowania niekorzystne dla systemu jednak większość z nich wnosi coś wartościowego a Dtube nie wnosi nic. Kompletnie nie rozumiem dlaczego jest wspierane :/

Moim zdaniem cel propagandowy. Bo jest platforma do wideo, a to, że nie zadziała ...

Thank STINC for that.
I agree that it's a good initial idea, but greed is hard to overcome.
There are people that create project(s) out of passion, others out of greed and sometimes it turns from passion to greed just from a large delegation aka misterdelegation, which is the case this time I think.

We'll see what happens. In the end, I prefer to leave myself, since money matters are being put above human affairs.

I noticed that some videos may or may not work depending on certain conditions, including your browser or a device (e.g. the film I have recently posted works fine on a PC but doesn't on a mobile).

Interesting observation, but it does not apply here. Bot does not test whether the movie works or does not work, only if it is on the network. If the network is unable to send anything for 60 seconds, the bot acknowledges that the video is unreachable.

You don't need Dtube to watch videos :)

Shame on you! Do you want to fight reward pool rape? There we go: https://steemit.com/@introduce.bot/comments scroll down and see who is voting, how much and how often on bot comments

Shame on you!

Thank you for the compliment

I do not remember that there was a pool rape list, I do not remember I would get money for searching for them.

But if you found such a person, write a post about it. Like me.

Hmmm... Check the title of own post

DTUBE DOES NOT WORK! REWARD POOL RAPE WARNING

Reward pool rape is not a single phenomenon. Many people use them. The most popular scandal was the registration of hundreds or thousands of accounts using Steemit and self-upvoting.

If you want the platform to be better - write about it.

What is wrong with this platform ? Search engine is not working at all, and it's like that for few weeks. Any ideas ?
Thank you.
Zrzut ekranu z 2019-02-22 22-51-58.png

I have not used Dube since they removed all my videos. But maybe the creator will help
@heimindanger

Do you know any other alternative platform to youtube ?
Thank You.

Vimeo, Dailymotion, cda.pl, Peertube