You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: New steem.io launch!

in #steem7 years ago

I actually wrote about this a month ago. https://steemit.com/steemit/@vimukthi/we-are-human-asics-steem-ponzi-scheme-explained-debunked

Compared to gold, Cryptos aren't REAL. They are not Tangible. Cryptos are not real assets. They have value because of what they can do. Cryptos are the hyper-gold except for being REAL. Most cryptos are mined or minted in a POW or PoS process. I see STEEM not as a social media but as a non-PoW non-PoS mining/minting process. Just think for a moment what if we could replace the Hashes and piggy back on social media activity instead.

What I love the most is the whole process having an intrinsic value. Even in PoS mining, the token/coin creation process itself has no value on its own. Steemit has built the single best mass community on the net and used the community itself as the mining process. It's Human Action within Human Action; 2 layers of pure capitalism.

Blocks are produced using DPoS. But the rewards are allocated based on the activity within the eco system. Instead of how many hashes you can do, steemit creates a system where it's about getting the most upvotes by providing value to the community. It's value on top of value. Proof of Brain/Creativity/Contribution is simply a term to describe piggy backing the token creation process on an intrinsically valuable system of Human Action.

Sort:  

I like the idea that tokens are created based on users's contributions ( even if technically not true), what I don't like is the word used to express this idea.

Token Are created based on users's contributions. But they are not created by the contributions or the contributors. Creation is done by DPoS and the created tokens are distributed based on user's contributions measured by the received upvotes.

In a DPoS system, the token creators tend to be much similar to mining pools than miners. This isn't a perfect allegory. But it's an interesting observation I've come across.

Token Are created based on users's contributions

This is wrong. Tokens are created at a fixed rate by block. They are then distributed to users according to voting.

But they are not created by the contributions or the contributors

Which is why it's not "proof of brain"