You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: BlockTrades Witness Report for 3rd Week of August
Sorry, nobody deserves that kind of money for taking 10 minutes to write an update that is going to allow them to earn more by being a witness... Might deserve a vote if you didn't upvote yourself, but, you did.
Pretty sure I didn't request your vote, bernie :-) As a side note, it takes me far longer than 10 minutes to write up one of these posts.
@berniesanders
Can you, please, explain why upvoting yourself is a bad thing? It looks like it doesn't have any effect, anyways.
And if it is a bad thing, then why there is a checkbox under the post?
Thanks a lot for the answer. I will be the guideline for future posts (and comments).
It is a bad thing for @blocktrades to self-vote here because it takes rewards from potential new users. @blocktrades, while a good witness, received over 8,000,000 vesting shares from the steemit company on 3/31/2016 and 4/1/2016. To vote for their own post is to use these given shares to award themselves hundreds of dollars at the expense of potential user base.
Even for @blocktrades, giving one's self an award is arguably legitimate in some cases, like for an essay or investigative piece, but a witness update adds very little to the value of steem content. A witness update has limited relevance to most potential users and, like @berniesanders mentions, is merely a justification for earnings elsewhere.
@steemed
Thanks for a long explanation :)
To sum it up:
Correct?
I don't agree with the blanket statement, and that isn't what @steemed said either. Indeed one of the benefits of SP, including owning a lot of it, is being able to promote your own posts.
The issue specifically is generating large rewards on a witness report that is already reporting on the process of earning rewards as a witness. It is unnecessary and effectively a form of double dipping.
In fact this is one of the reasons I don't make these posts myself. It reminds me of politicians who send out newsletters claiming to tell everyone about service to the community, but in fact are thinly disguised campaign ads. If what you are doing adds value then it ought to be easy for people to identify what it is you are doing without another post specifically advertising it.
I'm not sure why you think that. Voting for yourself generates rewards the same way any other vote does.
@smooth
Thanks for your expressed doubt :)
The answer is probably hidden because of this rule:
If this rule is in fact valid - I don't know that - and if only I (with my limited SP) vote for myself then I get - nothing.
Correct?
TNX!!!
That would explain it!
@berniesanders lol, yeah I think also it was done by some other users here